The longer I work in the Employee Plans section of the Internal
Revenue Service, and the more I meet folks like you and others trying
to save for retirement, the more enthusiastic I become in wanting every
person in America to have the ability to save for retirement.
We do have a huge coverage gap in this country. We have a
tremendous private pension system, with tens of millions of American
families benefiting from defined benefit plans, 401(k) plans, other
retirement plans, and also from IRAs that are outside the employer-
sponsored plan system. However, we also have tens of millions of
families not participating in any of those systems. They're not eligible for
a 401(k) or retirement plan because their employer and it is in a
voluntary system has chosen not to adopt a plan.
Recent statistics inform us that more than half more than half of the
American working population do not have access to a retirement plan.
When the statisticians take a deeper look into these numbers, a lot of
these workers are employed by firms with fewer than 50 employees.
The estimate is that 17 million workers are in the category of working for
an employer with fewer than 50 employees but not covered by an
1
employer-sponsored plan.
And that brings us to today's discussion. There are two popular plan types
available to small business employers that they can adopt and cut into this 17
million number. The first one is called a SEP, or a Simplified Employee
Pension plan. The SEP plan allows plan sponsors to contribute to traditional
IRAs set up for the employees. And a self-employed business can adopt a
SEP.
The other plan I will discuss today is the SIMPLE IRA plan. "SIMPLE" stands
for Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees. The SIMPLE IRA plan is
ideally suited as a start-up retirement plan for small business employers who
currently do not sponsor a retirement plan.
What I'm gonna do today is take you on a tour of both plans, providing to you
the similarities and differences when it comes time to choose and establish
one of these plans. Then the tour will continue to discuss about the
participation requirements of both plans. And finally, as the title suggests, we'll
get into the pitfalls or the recurring errors that we find in our examinations of
these plans. I will do my best to describe each error and then share with you
how to find, fix, and avoid these common errors.
By the end of this presentation, I hope that you will leave the session, contact
your clients about choosing and establishing one of these plans, and then
assist them in ensuring their plan does not have the recurring errors we
discuss here today. And before I move on, if you do not have a retirement plan
for yourself or your employees, lead by example and adopt one of these plans
when you return to your office.
1
We'll start with choosing between a SEP and a SIMPLE IRA plan. A
SEP plan is available to any sized business, while a SIMPLE IRA is
generally limited to small businesses with 100 or fewer employees. A
growing business with a SIMPLE IRA plan needs to watch that 100-
employee limit closely as they expand.
To adopt a SEP or a SIMPLE IRA, we make it very easy. During this
presentation, I'm going to be saying "we make it very easy" a lot, reason
being we really want these employers to adopt these plans, so we
provide a lot of ways to make things easy for them to establish, monitor,
and run these plans.
So for a SEP, there is a Form 5305-SEP, called Simplified Employee
Pension Individual Retirement Accounts Contribution Agreement. All
they have to do is adopt that, it's on our website, and it's done. For
SIMPLE IRA plans, they can adopt the 5305-SIMPLE if they want the
employer to choose where the money is initially deposited, or they can
use the Form 5304-SIMPLE to set up the SIMPLE IRA plan that allows
each employee to choose where the IRA is established.
2
A couple of notes about these forms. First, these forms are not filed with the
IRS. The employer keeps the form in its records. Second, with regard to the
Form 5305-SEP, our exam agents are noticing a recurring error in their recent
audits. If you choose to use the Form 5305-SEP, you cannot have any other
retirement plan, except for another SEP. When an employer adopts a SIMPLE
IRA plan, the employer cannot have any other retirement plan regardless of
the method used to start the plan.
An employer can also establish a SEP or SIMPLE IRA with a prototype plan
through a mutual fund, bank, and insurance company. This financial institution
will send a plan in to us, the IRS. We approve it. Then they'll go out and try to
sell it to you and your clients to have a prototype plan, and that's what that is
called. There is also an individually designed SEP or SIMPLE IRA plan, but we
don't see too much of those. Those are very rare.
The reason why people use a prototype document or an individually designed
plan rather than the models, the employer can customize their SEP or SIMPLE
IRA more the way they would like it.
For both of these plan types, there are no filing requirements. You do not file a
Form 5500-series return. Employee contributions are not allowed with SEP
plans. SIMPLE IRA plans do allow employee contributions, which I will detail
when we reach the operating portion of the tour.
2
The next stop arrives at explaining the procedures to set up these
plans, and for the most part the procedures are very similar for both
plans. First the employer needs to select a financial institution to serve
as the trustee of respective IRAs that will hold each employee's
retirement plan assets. These accounts will receive the contributions
you make to the plan.
Now, I mentioned the election period. That is a 60-day period
immediately preceding January 1st, the beginning of the next plan year.
So in essence, that would be November 2nd to December 31st.
However, the dates of this period are modified if you set up a SIMPLE
IRA plan in midyear or if the 60-day period falls before the first day an
employee becomes eligible to participate in the SIMPLE IRA plan.
Again, to make things easy, if you set up your SIMPLE IRA plan either
using the Form 5304-SIMPLE or the Form 5305-SIMPLE models, you
can give each employee a copy of the signed form and that'll satisfy this
notification requirement.
The timing to set up these plans is different. You can establish a SEP
3
for a year, as late as the due date, including any extensions, of your business
income tax return for the year you want to establish the plan.
Setting up a SIMPLE IRA plan is a little more complex. You can set up a
SIMPLE IRA plan effective on any date from January 1st through October 1st
of the year. To have a SIMPLE IRA in place for January 1st, 2016, it must be
adopted by November 2nd, 2015, to accommodate the 60-day election period.
If you previously maintained a SIMPLE IRA plan, you can set up a SIMPLE
IRA plan effective only on January 1st of a year.
One difference here would be if the employer chooses to adopt the plan using
the 5304-SIMPLE, which allows each participant to select the financial
institution for receiving his or her SIMPLE IRA plan contributions. Financial
institutions authorized to hold and invest SEP and SIMPLE IRA plan
contributions are banks, savings and loan associations, insurance companies,
certain regulated investment companies, federally-insured credit unions, and
brokerage firms.
The next required item to do for both plans is execute a written agreement to
adopt a plan, and that's what we just discussed. You can use the Form 5305-
SEP, 5304-SIMPLE, 5305-SIMPLE, or prototype plan.
The next requirement is to notify the eligible employees about the plan. For a
SEP plan, the employer is required to notify each eligible employee that the
SEP was adopted, the requirements for receiving an allocation, and how the
employer contribution will be allocated.
You must also provide the following to each employee: the Form 5305-SEP, if
that's what you use to adopt the plan; a statement that IRAs other than the one
the employer contributes to may provide different rates of return and contain
different terms; a statement that the administrator of the SEP will provide a
copy of any amendments within 30 days of the effective date, along with a
written explanation of its effects. And the administrator will give written
notification to the participant of any employer contributions made to the
participant's IRA by January 31st of the following year.
For SIMPLE IRA plans, they're required to have an annual notice for all eligible
employees. The employer must notify each employee before the beginning of
3
the election period of the following: the employee's opportunity to make or
change a salary reduction choice under the SIMPLE IRA plan; the employee's
ability to select a financial institution that will serve as trustee of the
employee's SIMPLE IRA if that's applicable; your decision to make either
matching contributions or nonelective contributions; a summary description
(and the financial institution usually provides that); and written notice that the
employee can transfer his or her balance without cost or penalty if you are
using a designated financial institution.
3
I'm now going to discuss the participation requirements of these plans,
and I'll start with the SEP plans. An eligible employee for a SEP plan is
an individual who meets all of the following requirements: has reached
age 21; has worked for the employer in at least three of the last five
years; and received at least $600.00 in compensation from the
employer during the year.
Two items tonight with this definition. First, employees also include a
self-employed individual, and the $600.00 amount is for this year, 2015.
Cost-of-living adjustments could change this amount from year to year.
Around mid-October they release any cost-of-living adjustments. You
can go to our website to see any changes to any amounts such as this.
To further explain the SEP requirement, allow me to introduce Sephora.
Sephora is a freshman at Huxley University, where she is getting her
degree in hippology. Does anybody what hippology is? It's the study of
a horse. Now, Huxley University and a horse, what movie am I
referencing? No Marx Brothers fans here, huh? Horse Feathers. The
prize goes back in the hopper, sorry.
4
Sephora worked for Barney's Barns during her summer break in school in the
year 2011, 2012, and 2013, but never more than 34 days in any year. Sephora
turned 21 in July 2014. In August 2014, Sephora began working for Barney's
on a full-time basis, and she earned $18,000.00 in 2014. So Sephora is an
eligible employee for Barney's Barns' SEP for 2014 because she met the
minimum age requirement, 21; she worked for Barney in three of the five
preceding years; and she met the minimum compensation requirement for
2014.
For a SIMPLE IRA plan, the requirements are different. Any eligible employee
would be one who, one, earned at least $5,000.00 in compensation during any
two years before the current calendar year and, two, expects to receive at
least $5,000.00 during the current calendar year. As in a SEP, an individual
can be a self-employed individual. Employers cannot impose any other
conditions for participating in a SIMPLE IRA plan, such as an age requirement.
Now, both the SEP and the SIMPLE IRA can have less restrictive
requirements if they choose. For instance, an employer could have a minimum
age of 18 in a SEP, or in a SIMPLE IRA they could make the compensation
$2,000.00, they could make it $1.00. It's their choice.
Both plans can also exclude certain classes of employees. And these are, one,
employees covered by a union agreement and whose retirement benefits were
bargained for good faith by the employees' union and the employer; and two,
nonresident alien employees who do not have U.S. wages, salaries, or other
personal services compensation from the employer. This should be “to note”
4
Our tour trolley now stops at the operating/maintaining features of these
plans, and, again, I'll begin with SEP plans. Let's begin with the
contribution amounts and limitations. Remember, no employee
contributions are permitted in SEP plans. Employer contributions for
each eligible employee is based only on the first $265,000.00 of
compensation. Employers must contribute a uniform percentage of pay
for every eligible employee. And for 2015, contributions are limited to
the lesser of $53,000.00 or 25 percent of compensation.
For self-employed individuals, figuring your own SEP IRA contribution
gets a little bit more complicated. Compensation is your net earnings
from self-employment, less deductions due to contributions to your own
SEP IRA, and one-half of your self-employment tax. And, again, to
make things easy, we have a Publication 560, called Retirement Plans
for Small Business. And this provides detailed explanations and
worksheets for these rules, and what I suggest is you use this
publication to determine your self-employed contribution amounts.
There is no requirement that a SEP contribution is made in every year.
When you do contribute, however, you must contribute to the SEP IRAs
5
of all eligible participants, including employees who die or terminate
employment before the contributions are made. Also, contribution to SEP
accounts are always 100 percent vested or owned by the employee.
Employer contributions to a SEP must be made by the due date, including any
extensions, for filing your federal income tax return for that year. Once you
send the SEP contributions to each eligible employee's IRA, that employee
makes all the investment decisions for his or her own account. SEP
contributions can be invested in stocks, mutual funds, money market funds,
savings accounts, and other similar types of investments. Employees can
move their SEP IRA assets from one traditional IRA to another.
Employees could take a distribution from their SEP IRA at any time.
Withdrawals are taxable in the year received. If the participant makes a
withdrawal before age 59.5, there is a 10 percent additional tax that generally
applies. We do have a publication on our website it's Publication 5036 that
provides a list of the exceptions to that 10 percent additional tax on early
distributions. I advise you to go there to look at that to see if any exceptions
apply.
I know the financial institutions my parents use are on top of the required
minimum distribution rolls, sometimes referred to as RMD rolls. And they do
make certain the required minimums are distributed to them. However, on our
examinations, we do see where these RMD payments are not made. If you do
not take the minimum distribution required, you may have to pay a 50, five-
zero, excise tax on the amount distributed as required. And trust me, nobody
wants to deal with that tax. So we suggest that you work with your financial
institution to ensure these distributions are made as required.
SEP contributions and earnings may be rolled over tax-free to other IRAs and
retirement plans. Our website has another tool. It's a rollover chart. It doesn't
have a publication number. I suggest on our homepage, go into the search
engine and type in "rollover chart," and it will be the first thing that shows up.
And it helps you determine whether you can roll over amounts from your SEP
IRA and the plan types where the SEP IRA can receive a rollover. Participant
loans are never permitted in SEP plans. But contributions can still be made for
the employees that have reached age 70.5 .
Again, here is some filing and notice requirements and tips. Remember, the
5
employer generally has no filing requirements, including the Form 5500-series
return. Here's a friendly reminder not to include SEP contributions on the
employee's Form W-2. Instead, check the Retirement Plan box, Box 13. And,
again, remember, the employer must provide notice to the employees, which
includes the Form 5305-SEP or the prototype, any amendments, the
requirements for receiving contributions, and the annual contribution
statement. Might be easier to have written “seventy and a half.”
5
Now let's move over to look at the operation of a SIMPLE IRA plan.
Again, you're gonna find some similarities and you're gonna find some
differences that we discussed with SEP.
The SIMPLE IRA is funded two ways: employee elective deferrals and
employer contributions, and we'll start with employer contributions. The
employer must annually choose one of the two contribution methods.
The employer could either make a fixed contribution of 2 percent of pay
for all eligible employees, even for those who do not elect to defer
salary into the plan, or they can match employee contributions dollar for
dollar, 100 percent, up to 3 percent of compensation. The match can be
reduced to as low as 1 percent, but no more than two calendar years
out of the five.
The second way a SIMPLE IRA is funded is through employee salary
deferrals. The amount the employee can defer for 2015 is $12,500.00.
For employees age 50 or over, a catch-up contribution in the amount of
$3,000.00 is allowed. There are salary deferral limits also for those
employees in more than one plan. The elective deferral limit for an
employee with more than one plan is $18,000.00. I suggest you visit our
6
website for other limitations when employees are participating in more than
one plan.
Some employers set up an automatic enrollment feature in a SIMPLE IRA
plan. What the automatic enrollment feature allows, it allows the employer to
automatically deduct a fixed percentage or amount from the employee's wages
and contribute that to the SIMPLE IRA plan, unless the employee has
affirmatively chosen to contribute nothing or to contribute a different amount.
And these automatic enrollment payments qualify as elective deferrals.
Employees have the option to elect to terminate their salary reduction
contributions to a SIMPLE IRA plan at any time. If they do so, the SIMPLE IRA
plan may preclude them from resuming salary reduction contributions until the
beginning of the next calendar year. Employers that are making non-elective
employer contributions must continue to make them on behalf of these
employees.
An employer's 3 percent match or 2 percent non-elective contribution is
required to be deposited by the due date again, with any extensions for
filing your federal income tax return for the year. Employee salary reduction
contributions are required to be deposited within 30 days after the end of the
month for which the amounts would otherwise have been payable to the
employee in cash. For a self-employed person, the Schedule C filer, salary
reduction contributions must be deposited within 30 days of the end of the plan
year, or January 30th.
Withdrawal rules for SIMPLE IRA contributions and earnings are the same as I
described the SEP plans, with one minor difference. The 10 percent additional
tax increases to 25 percent if the withdrawal occurs within the first two years of
participation. Rollovers are permitted between one SIMPLE IRA to another
SIMPLE IRA, tax free. A tax-free rollover may also be made from a SIMPLE
IRA to an IRA that is not a SIMPLE IRA, but, again, only after two years of
participation in the SIMPLE IRA plan.
Also, like SEP plans, loans are never permitted. And, again, there is no Form
5500-series filing requirement. And the notification election period is, again,
generally the 60-day period immediately preceding January 1st of the calendar
year, November 2nd to December 31st. And the dates of this period are
modified if you set up a SIMPLE IRA plan in midyear or if the 60-day period
6
falls before the first day an employee becomes eligible to participate in the
SIMPLE IRA plan.
6
Now we enter the part of the tour that provides the recurring errors our
examination agents are finding when they audit SEP and SIMPLE IRA
plan. Again, I'll provide details as best as I can and give you tips how to
find, fix, and avoid these errors. The first part of this segment is the
most common errors we find in both plans.
The first error you see involves plans not being amended at all or not
timely. Specifically, there was a law passed called the Economic Growth
and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001, commonly known as
EGTRRA. EGTRRA provides higher compensation limits and
contribution limits. The plans, when using these new limits, must amend
their plans accordingly. So with the SIMPLE IRA plan, for instance, no
plan amendment means the employee's not being notified of these new
limits.
To find this mistake, if you're using the IRS Form 5305-SEP, 5304-
SIMPLE, or 5305-SIMPLE, check the latest revision date in the top left-
hand corner. Anything earlier than December 2004 could indicate a
problem. You can find these forms on our website. If we have a newer
form on the website, check to see if you need to adopt that latest
7
version. A good chance is that you will.
If the plan's sponsor chose to use a prototype plan, we suggest you contact
the financial institution for a current letter noting that the IRS approves the plan
for current law. To fix the mistake, you would adopt the current IRS model plan
form, or prototype, whichever one you're using, and then complete a Voluntary
Correction Program, or VCP, submission. And I'll discuss this program later.
To avoid this mistake, I suggest that the plan sponsor do a yearly check of the
plan, whether it be looking for the model form on the website or contacting the
financial institution about the prototype plan, to ensure the current plan is in
use.
Our examination agents wanted me to add two tips for you. First, for those of
you using a prototype plan, please ensure the adoption agreement is signed
and dated. An unsigned or undated adoption agreement usually results in the
agent determining the plan is not amended for current law. When we talk to
taxpayers, they receive it in the mail and they think they just need to add it to
their plan and don't do anything else with it. Very important that your client sign
and date these adoption agreements.
It's also very useful for the exam agents to have the IRS opinion letter from the
financial institution that sold you the prototype plan, 'cause this enables the
agent to confirm that the plan is current. Second, be familiar with the plan
document and plan terms, and make certain the operation of the plan is in line
with the plan language.
And with that, that provides me an easy segue to the next common recurring
error in SEP and SIMPLE IRA plans. Exam agents find that the definition of
compensation in the plan is not being followed. And specifically, and recently in
SIMPLE IRA plans, we're finding that there is a failure to include bonus
payments as compensation from the matching employer contribution. We're
not sure why this is a recurring error, but we are bringing it up for your
attention.
Again, to find this mistake, we suggest a yearly spot-check to confirm that the
same compensation as defined by the plan is being used in plan operation.
And this is more important if you adopted a prototype plan and it contains a
7
complicated definition. You have bonuses; you have car allowances; you have
expense reimbursements; you have overtime. And these are just a few
examples that may or may not be included in the plan definition.
To fix this mistake in a SEP, you would need to make a corrective contribution,
which include earnings through the correction date, to each affected
employee's SEP IRA. And if you cannot determine the actual investment
results, you can use a reasonable rate of interest. The Department of Labor
has an online calculator for their Voluntary Correction Program, which uses a
reasonable interest rate, and this is a good place to find the interest rate to
use.
For an error in a SIMPLE IRA, the correction's a bit more complicated because
of elective deferrals. You must make corrective contributions to the employee's
SIMPLE IRA equal to the following: one, 50 percent of the employee's elective
deferral percentage under the plan times the excluded compensation; plus the
employer contribution required under the plan times the excluded
compensation. As I mentioned with SEP plans, you would also need to include
earnings to the date of correction.
To avoid this error, I would recommend doing the same thing I mentioned for
finding the error: continue a yearly review and spot-check a few calculations
from the participants to ensure the plan definition is the same as used in
operation. If the plan is amended, make sure to change to the compensation
definition what the plan sponsor intended and the change is communicated to
the people who calculate the contributions. And sometimes what we see as
just a simple error where they get a new adoption agreement, and there might
be just a wrong check of a box and the employer's not aware that he or she
checked the box and it leads to issues, so, again, just do a yearly check to
make sure that what's being done according to the adoption agreement's being
done in operation.
The next recurring error involves improperly excluding participants from the
plan. In SEP plans, this is the most common error found by our exam agents
today. Let's revisit the SEP eligibility requirements: reached age 21, has
worked for the employer at least three of the last five years, and received at
least $600.00 in compensation from the employer during the year.
Now, in 401(a) plans, such as profit-sharing and 401(k) plans, they usually
7
require an employee to work 1,000 hours of service to receive a contribution.
Our agents are finding administrators using the same requirement for the SEP
plans. Remember Sephora in my example? I purposely had her working less
than 1,000 hours to make that point. I mentioned she only worked 34 days a
year.
Another related finding by the exam agent is employees are excluded because
they're labeled as a part-time employee. Again, if the employee meets those
three requirements I just mentioned, they should be participating in the plan.
To find this mistake, we suggest that you review payroll data and determine if
employees are meeting either the SEP or SIMPLE IRA plan eligibility
requirements and if they are included in participating in the plan. If you find any
problems in the spot check, I suggest the spot check be expanded to more
employees to determine if there is a larger problem that needs fixed.
To fix this error in a SEP plan is the same correction as I mentioned for the
compensation definition error. The employer must set up a SEP IRA for the
employee and make a contribution equal to all missed contributions plus
earnings.
Correction in a SIMPLE IRA is a bit more complicated. First, the employee
didn't have a chance to make an election to defer, otherwise known as a
missed deferral opportunity. So what the IRS safe harbor correction method
assumes, that the employee would've elected to defer 3 percent of
compensation. The required corrective contribution to replace the missed
deferral opportunity is 50 percent of the missed deferral or 1.5 percent of
compensation plus earnings.
In a SIMPLE IRA, if the employer chose the matching option, they must make
a 3 percent contribution plus earnings to that employee's SIMPLE IRA. If
under the plan the employer contribution is a 2 percent non-elective
contribution, then the correction contributions should include a contribution of 2
percent of compensation, again, plus earnings.
Avoiding this error is very similar to the compensation error. Review the
participation status of employees at least once a year. And for SIMPLE IRA
plans, I suggest that this review be completed prior to the election period that
7
begins on November 2nd, so you can provide the affected employees the
notice as required timely.
The last recurring error found in both plans involves employees of related
businesses that are excluded from participating in the plan. Related
businesses include controlled groups of corporations that include your
business, trades or businesses under common control with your business, and
affiliated service groups that include your business. This means, for example,
that if you and your family members own a controlling interest in another
business, the employees at that other business are employees for purposes of
determining who's eligible to participate in the SEP.
To find this mistake, all owners or partners of your business should identify any
companies they own or with which they have a financial relationship. If any of
these companies a relationship exist, review the controlled group and affiliated
service group requirements to ensure that all required employees are included
in the plan. Now, this determination of these groups gets very complex at
times, so I suggest getting help at making that proper determination if you
think you have this situation.
To fix this mistake, you correct the exact same way I mentioned for the
excluded participants error. And to avoid this error, we suggest you do an initial
assessment, as you would to find the mistake, and then perform a quick
assessment each year, especially if you or a family member gets involved in
another or new business.
7
So now I'm gonna explain some recurring errors that we're finding in
SEP exams. First, contribution allocations are done improperly.
Generally, employer contributions to participant SEP IRAs must be
equal to the same percentage of compensation for each participant. For
instance, every employee gets 7 percent of compensation. What our
agents are finding is that higher-paid employees are sometimes
receiving a greater percentage of compensation than the lower-paid
employees.
Correction would be similar to what I mentioned before. In general,
place the affected employees in a position they would've been in had
the mistake not occurred, and also remember to include earnings.
Exam agents are also finding SEP IRA contributions are exceeding the
maximum limit. You may hear the term "415 limits." That is in reference
to the Internal Revenue Code section that sets these limits. And for
2015, the amount of contributions made to an employee's SEP IRA are
limited to the lesser of $53,000.00 or 25 percent of compensation. And,
again, remember to review the special calculations in Pub 560 for the
self-employed individuals.
8
The general correction method is distribute any excess from the SEP IRA and
return it to the employer. I would suggest that someone verify that none of the
allocations exceed these limitations before money is transferred to the SEP
IRA.
SEP plans are prohibited from having salary deferrals, but our agents are
finding SEP plans that are trying to provide these deferrals. If an employer or
one of your clients wishes to have a salary deferral, what we suggest is they
terminate the SEP plan and then adopt a SIMPLE IRA plan. We also see some
SEP plans that are allowing catch-up contributions. These are not permitted in
SEP plans.
Finally, we're also finding that required minimum distributions are not made
because the employee is still working. These are required regardless of
whether you're still employed.
8
The recurring errors we're finding exclusively in SIMPLE IRA plans are
becoming very prevalent. Please take a look at your SIMPLE IRA plans
for the following. If you remember back to my discussion of operating a
SIMPLE IRA, I mentioned the matching limit should not be reduced in
more than two calendar years during the five-year period ending with
the calendar year. Exam agents are finding this error more in recent
audits. So for example, if you only gave a 1 percent match in 2010 and
2011, then for 2012, 2013, and 2014 you must give the full 3 percent
match. They're also finding incorrect matching amounts, including none
made.
Correction is similar to what I mentioned before. Again, place the
affected employees in a position they would've been if the mistake was
not made, and, again, include earnings.
Next, we are finding more late deposits of salary deferral payments to
IRAs. The Department of Labor, or DOL, requires the transfer at the
earliest date which the employer can reasonably segregate the
contributions. They also have a seven-day safe harbor to deposit these
deferrals. Deposits after that date could lead to corrective contributions
9
to make up for any lost earnings. The IRS requirement is 30 days following the
month in which you withheld deferrals from the employee's salary. If you
deposit it beyond the 30 days, it could disqualify the SIMPLE. And a tip: Most
SIMPLE IRA plans are subject to the Department of Labor rules I mentioned
here.
Finally, exam agents are finding employers are not providing the 60-day notice
as required. Items that need to be shared with eligible employees prior to
November 2nd include their right to make a salary deferral election, notification
of the employer's decision to make a fixed or matching contribution, and the
other ones I mentioned earlier in this presentation. Failure to give this
notification could lead to some extensive plan corrections. I suggest
establishing administrative procedures to provide an alert when it's time to
provide this yearly notification.
9
So I've discussed many errors today that we're finding in SEP and
SIMPLE IRA plans. And, again, the reason why we share these errors
with you is, you can go back and check your plans or your clients' plans
for these errors and make these corrections sooner rather than later.
This is also why we produced what you see on the screen. I suggest
you download this slide or this menu and share it with your clients.
Again, the message you wanna convey: It is far better to correct errors
sooner rather than later. We have three correction programs, and you
can see them across the top of the chart: audit CAP, voluntary
correction, and self-correction. All of the errors I discussed today can fit
into one or more of these programs, depending on many factors. I
suggest you visit our Correcting Plan Errors web page for more detailed
information. The link can be found on our homepage under the
Maintaining Your Plan section.
Getting back to this chart, starting at the far right you can see self-
correction. With self-correction, the cost of correction is small because
you caught the error early, maybe by using the suggestions I discussed
in this presentation today. Correction does not take much time, either,
10
for the same reasons: you caught it early. Also with self-correction, you can
see there are no IRS fees. As a matter of fact, you don't even have to contact
the IRS. What better program to use than the self-correction program?
The middle column represents our Voluntary Correction Program. If an error is
not eligible for self-correction, and I mentioned the non-amender I said you
have to file a VCP submission it is not available for self-correction, so you
would have to use voluntary correction if it was a non- or late amender. So you
would submit your errors to this IRS program.
As you can see from the chart, correction will take a little more money, more
time is involved, and you must submit a fee to have the plan correction method
approved by the IRS. Again, to make things easier or more apt for someone
with a SEP or SIMPLE IRA to do this correction, we've reduced the fee to
$250.00, where other 401(a) plans, such as your profit-sharing or 401(k) with
similar amount of employees, their VCP fee could be up to $2,500.00. So,
again, we want corrections made, and we want these plans to run smoothly,
and that's why we reduced these fees.
The column on the left represents the Audit Closing Agreement Program, or
audit CAP. This is when the IRS agent finds the error while performing an
examination of the SEP or SIMPLE IRA plan. The column tells the not-so-feel-
good story with this option. Corrections are gonna take more time and money,
because this error was not caught immediately. It might go five, six, seven
years back.
There is also a sanction amount that is negotiated between the plan sponsor
and the IRS, and that amount will always be higher than the $250.00 that's
available under the voluntary correction. So, again, if it helps, the reason why
we provide this is for you to download it, show it to your clients, and show
them the difference between the three programs, hopefully that they can look
for errors immediately, and when they find errors, they can make corrections
as soon as possible.
10
I brought up our website throughout this presentation. Some of you
might be thinking, "Well, what is this website he's talking about?" We
have it here on the screen. It is www.irs.gov/retirement. This is where
you'll find the Correcting Plan Errors page, which provides the detailed
information about the correction programs I just discussed.
And, again, to make process easier, we do have submission kits and fill-
in forms for the Voluntary Correction Program. So if someone wants to
use this program, we have a lot of the items right there. They just need
to fill them in. And it's easier to do the submission for voluntary
correction.
As I said many times today, a retirement plan needs regular care to
keep it operating properly. We have a one-page check sheet for SEP
and SIMPLE IRA plans, and each checklist links to a fix-it guide with
tips on how to find, fix, and avoid each potential error. Now, this
checklist is for your use on a voluntary basis. You do not file it with the
IRS. We've had some people go over the checklist, and they get all
marked yes, and it's "Dear IRS, We have them all yes. There's no need
to audit us. We're good." It doesn't really work that way.
11
Remember the checklists aren't meant as a comprehensive review. It's just an
easy way to start. Some of the sample questions include: Has your plan
document been updated within the past few years? Are the plan's operations
based on the plan document terms? Are all eligible employees participating in
the plan? Items we talked about today, and there are others. Answering no to
any of these checklist questions tells you that you may have a mistake in the
plan operation. The expanded explanation for each question gives you
examples of how to correct the mistake.
And then, finally, there are the SEP and SIMPLE IRA fix-it guides.
May contain tips on how to find, fix, and avoid common mistakes just as we
discussed today. Each guide provides an overview of the rules for each plan
type, an overview of the correction programs, the most frequent errors we find
in each plan type, and, again, tips on finding, fixing, and avoiding these
mistakes. As well with the slide I just mentioned, we encourage you to use and
share these tools with your clients.
11
There may come a time when you want to or are required to terminate
your plan. Now you're thinking, "Required to? When would that be?'
Remember the SIMPLE IRA plan and its limit of 100 employees. If your
company is expanding and you need more than 100 employees, the
SIMPLE IRA plan can't be used, so you wanna switch to another plan,
like a 401(k) plan. For both plans, you are not required to give the IRS
notice of the plan termination.
To terminate a SEP, notify the financial institution you will no longer be
contributing and you wanna terminate the contract or agreement. It is a
good idea to notify your employees that you have discontinued the plan.
To terminate a SIMPLE IRA, again, it's a little more complicated than a
SEP. I've probably said that four or five times today, and just the irony of
saying "with a SIMPLE it's more complicated."
First, notify your employees within a reasonable time before November
2nd that you'll discontinue the SIMPLE IRA plan effective the following
January 1st. So for example, if you decide to terminate your plan on
November 23rd, 2015, the earliest effective termination date is January
1st, 2017. You cannot terminate your SIMPLE IRA plan in the middle of
12
a year.
Next, notify your financial institution and payroll provider that you won't be
making SIMPLE IRA contributions for the next calendar year and you wanna
terminate your contributions. And finally, we recommend you keep records of
any and all of your actions.
We do our best to keep you current on the latest retirement plan news. On our
homepage, we have a box it's an orange box on the left-hand side that
provides the most current news on retirement plans, program updates, and
new law. I suggest you visit there regularly to get the latest news quickly.
Another option to get the news delivered to your inbox, we have two free
electronic newsletters that you can subscribe to. The first one is called
Employee Plans News, and this is geared towards more the practitioner
community, and it's more technically involved than our newsletter geared
toward plan sponsors, which is called Retirement News for Employers. It's a
Web-based product, and this newsletter will make an excellent reference
guide, as we fill them with embedded links to source materials on our website,
maybe sometimes a DOL website, et cetera.
Subscribing is easy. On our homepage, on the top left-hand side, there is a
link called Retirement Plans A-Z. That's our sitemap. Click on that. On the left-
hand side of that page, there is a link called Newsletters. Then either click on
Employee Plans News or Retirement News for Employers. You can subscribe
to both if you wish. Click on Subscribe and give us your email address, and
that's all it takes. We will send you links when we have a new newsletter, and
you can go in there and find the information you need.
We also provide monthly webinars on retirement plan topics. Click on the
Webinars link on the homepage to find upcoming webinar dates and topics.
We also keep an archive of the old webinars, so if there's something that you
missed and you can go back and find the transcript, sometimes the audio,
along with the PowerPoint, to go back and look at.
We also provide frequently asked questions, or FAQs, on over 25 topics,
including SEP and SIMPLE IRA plans and the correction programs. Many of
your questions can be answered here. And we also have an Examination and
12
Enforcement page. If the unlikely event that the SEP or SIMPLE gets selected
for audit, you can go here and see the steps that the agent will take, the
different forms that he or she will use, the questions they may ask, et cetera,
to get you ready for the examination.
12
13