-15-
GSE MODEL RESULTS
SCENARIO TITLE: Cost-Effectiveness Calculation Example (Baggage Tug)
EQUIPMENT CATEGORY: Baggage Tug
CURRENT TECHNOLOGY: Gas-4
NUMBER OF UNITS: 1
Emissions (tons/
ear)
Current Alternative Technologies
Gas-4
LPG CNG Diesel Electric
HC 1.148 - 0.574 0.382 0.217 0.006
CO 57.648 - 36.030 36.030 0.686 0.019
NOx 0.699 - 0.525 0.525 1.842 0.068
PM 0.007 - 0.006 0.006 0.136 0.004
Emission Reductions (tons/
ear)
Current Alternative Technologies
Gas-4
LPG CNG Diesel Electric
HC n/a - 0.57 0.77 0.93 1.14
CO n/a - 21.62 21.62 56.96 57.63
NOx n/a - 0.17 0.17 -1.14 0.63
PM n/a - 0.00 0.00 -0.13 0.00
Emission Reductions (%)
Current Alternative Technologies
Gas-4
LPG CNG Diesel Electric
HC n/a - 50.0% 66.7% 81.1% 99.4%
CO n/a - 37.5% 37.5% 98.8% 100.0%
NOx n/a - 25.0% 25.0% -163.3% 90.2%
PM n/a - 16.3% 16.3% -1758.9% 46.5%
NPV Lifetime Costs ($)
Current Alternative Technologies
Gas-4
LPG CNG Diesel Electric
Purchase Cost $17,000 - $19,000 $21,000 $22,000 $30,000
Replacement Cost $2,568 - $2,568 $2,568 $2,568 $6,566
Fuel Cost $59,481 - $49,072 $65,058 $27,386 $5,576
Maintenance Cost $47,089 - $37,176 $37,176 $47,089 $15,614
Total Cost $126,139 - $107,816 $125,802 $99,044 $57,756
NPV Lifetime Emissions (tons)
Current Alternative Technologies
Gas-4
LPG CNG Diesel Electric
HC 10.157 - 5.079 3.381 1.924 0.056
CO 510.265 - 318.916 318.916 6.076 0.164
NOx 6.190 - 4.643 4.643 16.302 0.606
PM 0.065 - 0.054 0.054 1.201 0.035
Weighted Total: Ozone 89.243 55.281 53.584 19.094 0.685
NPV Incremental Cost Savin
s ($)
Current Alternative Technologies
Gas-4
LPG CNG Diesel Electric
Purchase Cost n/a - -$2,000 -$4,000 -$5,000 -$13,000
Replacement Cost n/a - $0 $0 $0 -$3,997
Fuel Cost n/a - $10,409 -$5,576 $32,095 $53,905
Maintenance Cost n/a - $9,914 $9,914 $0 $31,475
Total Cost n/a - $18,323 $337 $27,095 $68,383
NPV Emission Reductions (tons)
Current Alternative Technologies
Gas-4
LPG CNG Diesel Electric
HC n/a - 5.079 6.776 8.233 10.101
CO n/a - 191.349 191.349 504.189 510.101
NOx n/a - 1.548 1.548 -10.112 5.584
PM n/a - 0.011 0.011 -1.136 0.030
Weighted Total: Ozone n/a 33.962 35.659 70.149 88.557
Incremental Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)
Current Alternative Technologies
Gas-4
LPG CNG Diesel Electric
HC n/a - $3,608 $50 $3,291 $6,770
CO n/a - $96 $2 $54 $134
NOx n/a - $11,839 $218 -$2,680 $12,245
PM n/a - $1,742,065 $32,057 -$23,842 $2,278,120
Weighted Total: Ozone n/a $540 $9 $386 $772
Figure 5
Sample GSEModel Results Report