40
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Increasing Third Grade’s Mastery of Simple Present Tense
Using Flashcards
Maya Sartika
Permai Elementary School, Jakarta
Abstract
Mastering the simple present tense can be very difficult for EFL young
learners because tenses contain abstract concepts that do not exist in the first
language of EFL learners. The third graders at Permai Elementary School,
North Jakarta, also encountered problems in mastering the tense when they
are taught using the lecture method. To solve the problem, action research
was conducted by using flashcards. The action research was carried out in
two cycles in August to October 2019. Involving 30 third graders, quantitative
and qualitative data were collected employing tests, observation, and
questionnaires. The findings revealed that flashcards use managed to increase
the students’ achievement in learning the simple present tense. The mean
scores of the three tests administered during the action research increased
from 36.69 to 65.73 and to 75.00. The use of flashcards also changed the
students’ attitude from mainly negative to mainly positive. The mean of the
positive responses increased from 20.4% in the pre-action survey to 83.89%
in the post-action survey.
Keywords: EFL, flashcards, simple present tense, young learners
INTRODUCTION
Despite the continuing debate on the status of grammar instruction in the field of English
as a second or foreign language (ESL/EFL) teaching and learning, various studies indicate
that EFL learners find explicit grammar instruction helpful. Since the number of
communicative input and the real-world required to activate the target language
communicative functions are limited, most EFL teachers tend to use grammar-based as
the norm (Male, 2011). In line with this, Cakir (2011) stated that systematic and
purposeful teaching of grammar is viewed vital to master the target language so that
grammar, either directly or indirectly, is taught in almost all levels of education.
e-ISSN: 2622-4224 | p-ISSN: 2087-9628
41
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
To activate the communicative function in every language, the speaker should
acquire the four language skills. To realize it, he or she should master the language
components, i.e. vocabulary and pronunciation and the system of operating these skills
and components, i.e. grammar. Without grammar mastery, it will be difficult to use the
language appropriately in appropriate situations.
One of the most important elements of English grammar to master by EFL learners
is tenses. However, most EFL learners, whose mother tongue does not belong to the Indo-
European family, find tenses difficult. The major reason is that the languages not included
in the Indo-European family, particularly in the Germanic groups have only the concept
of time but not tenses, while English has both time and tenses. Muhsin (2016) stated that
“Indonesian students find tenses to be most difficult to learn.” The following misused
sentences commonly produced by Indonesian students illustrate this phenomenon: *I live
in Medan two years ago, *We have finished the project yesterday, *I am know where she
put the book. The absence of tenses concept in their first language makes it hard for EFL
students to master and use the rules of tenses. Therefore, they frequently commit errors.
While teaching the third graders of Permai Elementary School, North Jakarta, I
found that the students continuously committed errors in using the simple present tense.
Most of them seemed to misunderstand why some sentences must use auxiliaries, is, am,
and are instead of auxiliaries do and does. I always encountered erroneous sentences they
produced like *My father is work in the office, *We are not study in the classroom, and
*He sweep the floor every morning. Many of them were also confused in determining
which subjects of sentences should use auxiliaries do and which ones should use does.
What is more, my trials to enable them to avoid such errors by explicitly explaining
related rules and analyzing the errors they committed seem fruitless.
Based on the pre-observations I conducted concerning the problems, I found that
the explicit grammatical rules instruction does not work well for students at their level of
education. Understanding the connection in the form of the verb and their concept of time
seemed very difficult for them to achieve merely by learning the rules. The results of my
ideas sharing with colleagues revealed that at the age of third graders, the students are
naturally curious and enthusiastic to discover the world around them to acquire new
experiences, including learning a new language. However, they can learn more effectively
through visual media.
After consulting some relevant literature, I found that one of the most effective
visual means for teaching tenses to young EFL learners is flashcards. Flashcards are cards
on which words or phrases or sentences are printed with or without pictures. Cross (1991)
defined a flashcard as a simple picture on a piece of paper or card, which is probably the
most widely visual aids in language teaching. To make them have higher positive effects
on students' visual learning process, the words and the pictures in flashcards need to be
printed clear and colorful. They can be used for any subjects, and for many students using
flashcards is a fun way to learn new vocabulary and grammar (Gelfgren, 2012). Some
previous studies (Widyarini, 2008; Nadziroh, 2010) revealed that flashcards are effective
to develop students’ vocabulary. Another study (Hartono, 2018) revealed that flashcards
improve students’ achievement in learning the present continuous tense. Realizing the
effectiveness of using flashcards to enhance students’ learning, including tenses, I finally
decided to conduct an action research by using the learning media to help my students
improve their mastery of the simple present tense.
42
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
Specifically, this study addressed the following research questions: (1) Does the
use of flashcards improve the third graders’ mastery of the simple resent tense at Permai
Elementary School, Jakarta? (2) How does the use of flashcards improve the third graders
at Permai Elementary School, Jakarta? This action research can hopefully shed light on
the way and the benefits of using flashcards in young learners’ EFL classrooms.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Simple Present Tense
The simple present expresses habitual or everyday activities, events or situations. The
events or situations exist now, have existed in the past, and probably will exist in the
future (Azar, 2002). Specifically, the simple present is a verb tense with four main uses.
First, it is used to express repeated or regular actions in the present time, e.g. She takes
Bus 22 to her office and The train leaves every 20 minutes. Second, it is used to reveal
facts, e.g., A cat has four legs and The earth is a planet. Third, it is used to express habits.
E.g., I wake up at 5.00 every morning and They visit their country house every weekend.
Fourth, it is used to express things that are always true. E.g., They use English in the
classroom and Indonesia consists of more than 17,000 islands.
To master the simple present tense, it is essential to be familiar with three elements:
verb conjugation, verb form, and verb function. These three elements can be very
challenging for most EFL learners, especially if they still have limited knowledge about
language structure. Therefore, the teaching tenses to primary school students might not
be the same as teaching them to adults. EFL primary school students have less proficiency
and knowledge about English tenses. Therefore, teachers have to be more creative in
teaching them. There are many ways to improve students' mastery in the simple present
tense, and one of them is by using flashcards. Male (2018) stated that the use of flashcards
as a media can be effectively used in teaching grammar. Also, if used appropriately,
flashcards are a powerful memory tool (Edwards, 2006).
Flashcards
A flashcard is a paper or cardboard containing words, phrases or sentences with or
without pictures Kasihani (2007) defined flashcard as cards measure A4 papers amount
to 30 to 50 cards and every card contains a picture and name of the picture. Additionally,
Halliwel (1992) defined flashcards as a kind of card contains pictures, words, instructions
that are arranged in various combinations.
Flashcards are easy to make, and they can be used for any subjects. In language
teaching, using flashcards can be a fun way to learn vocabulary, vocabulary, and
grammar. They can also be used to facilitate reading, discussion, role play, and quiz
(Gelfgren, 2012). Thus, these media can effectively help English teachers to present
learning materials in various ways of learning and teaching activities. They also help
students to understand their teachers’ explanations in interesting ways. Eslahcar (2012:
137) stated, "Flashcards are useful for drilling new letters, syllables, words, and other
information. … Flashcards can bear vocabulary, historical dates, formulas or any subject
matter that can be learned via a question and answer format."
The inclusion of pictures on flashcards is valuable because appropriate pictures
bring the image of reality into the abstract concepts encountered in language learning.
Joklova (2009) posited that “The picture is used in a more meaningful and “real-life
communicative‟ way than being just displayed for students to say what they can see. This
will probably have a greater impact on the retention of a piece of vocabulary again and
43
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
also subsequently on the ability to use it in communication” (p. 19). Pictures do not only
bring images of reality but also present fun element in the class (Hill, 1990).
Flashcards' effectiveness could increase if text and pictures are colorful because
young learners are interested in something unique and colorful. That's why the use of
visual aids such as pictures, charts, and flashcards is highly recommended in the teaching-
learning process. The study of Cuban (2001) indicated that 1% of what is learned is from
the sense of taste, 1.5% of what is learned is from the sense of touch, 3.5% of what is
learned is from the logic of smell, 11% of what is educated is from the logic of hearing
and 83% of what is learned is from the sense of sight. Studying with visual media is
effective, enjoyable and interesting to young learners.
METHOD
This study is an action research design which is defined by Pardede (2016) as “a
principled way of observing one's teaching, reflecting upon it, and trying to analyze its
weaknesses and increase its strengths. through which educators can help themselves
and their students overcome the specific problems they encounter in the learning and
teaching process” (p.143). In this study, the investigated teaching context or the action
implemented is the teaching of the simple present tense by using flashcards.
The action research was implemented in the the four-stage cyclical process, i.e.
plan, action, observe, and reflect. In details, the 14 steps described by Pardede (2019)
were followed in the implementation. During the implementation, quantitative and
qualitative data were collected to see whether flashcards could increase third-grade
students' mastery of simple present tense and how the process takes place. The
quantitative data was the students’ pre-test and post-test scores, and the qualitative data
were collected through observation and a questionnaire.
This study was carried out in two cycles in August to October 2019. Each cycle
was held in four sessions, and each session was held in 40 minutes). The participants were
the students 30 third-graders, 16 females and 14 males, of Permai Elementary School
located in North Jakarta.
FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION
This study was undertaken by following four steps, i.e., planning, action, observation, and
reflection. In the planning step, I designed the lesson plan, flashcards, pretest, posttest,
observation sheet, and question items for the questionnaire. The action step referred to
the application of the entire planned activities. To guarantee its effectiveness, the
observation assisted by the teacher-collaborator was conducted. The data obtained
through the tests, observation, and a questionnaire were then evaluated in the reflection
phase. With the teacher-collaborator, the results of the reflection have done to trace the
effectiveness and success of the action implemented. The effectiveness consisted of the
strengths and weakness of the flashcards and the students’ mastery of the simple present
tense as measured by the tests and percentage of the achieved success criterion.
Initial Students Attitude and Mastery of the Simple Present Tense
Before the research was conducted, the students seemed to have no enthusiasm in learning
English and their mastery of the simple present tense is low. As shown by Table 1, 76%
of them got a low score category, and the rest 23.33% got a fair score category. The mean
score of the class pretest is 36.93. It is very far below the Standard Minimum Criteria
(SMC), i.e., 75 points.
44
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
Table 1
Students’ Pre-test Scores
Category
Frequency
Percentage
Very Good
0
0%
Good
0
0%
Fair
7
23.33%
Low
23
76,67%
Total
30
100%
Mean score: 36.93
The students’ attitude towards English in general and the simple present tense
before the action research is shown in Table 2. The table, which recapitulates the students'
responses to the questionnaire administered soon after they took the pretest, shows that
the majority of them disliked learning English and thought the simple present tense was
uninteresting. They also thought the learning activity, i.e. listening to the teacher's lecture
did not help them master the tense.
Table 2
The Result of the Pre-Action Questionnaire
No
Statements
YES
NO
f
%
f
%
1
I like learning English.
10
33.33
20
66.67
2
Learning the Simple Present is interesting.
6
20.00
24
80.00
3
The Simple Present is easy to learn
5
16.67
25
83.33
4
Learning activities help me understand the simple
present tense
2
6.67
28
93.33
5
The exercises on the Simple Present Tense are easy
to do
7
23.33
23
76.67
Total
30
102
120
399
Mean
6
20.4
24
79.6
Report of Cycle 1
This cycle was conducted on 5 August to 2 September 2019. In the first session, the pretest
and survey using the pre-action questionnaire were administered. The second to the fifth
sessions were employed to teach the verb conjugation and spelling in the positive
sentences of the simple present tenses. During the action implementation, a collaborator
was asked to make an observation.
1. Planning
This step was carried out to plan the topics most important to solve identified through the
analysis made on the pre-test results. Based on the analysis results, the flashcards needed
during the four sessions were made. The size of each flashcard I used was half of the
legal-size paper (about 11X18 cm). In each flashcard, I printed a simple present tense
sentence and a picture that is closely connected to the sentence context.
2. Acting
In the first meeting which was held on Monday, 12 August 2019, all students were
present. After greeting and checking the student’s presence, the learning activities began
by showing the students the flashcards revealing some sentences related to “My daily
45
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
Activities" The first session was not very conducive yet, because some students seemed
uninterested in the flashcards. According to the observer, the students sitting in the back
rows could not clearly see the words and pictures on the flashcards. She suggested the
researcher prepare flashcards containing bigger fonts and pictures in the following
sessions. Based on this suggestion, the flashcards I used in the next sessions were about
21X29.7 cms, i.e. by using A4 paper. In the second, third and fourth sessions, the students
tended to become more interesting and more involved in the learning activities. The cycle
was ended by asking the students to do the posttest of cycle 1.
3. Observing
As described in the acting step above, the observation result of the first session
recommended the researcher to prepare flashcards containing bigger fonts and pictures in
the following sessions. This managed to increase the students’ interest and make them
more involved in learning activities. The results of the posttest of cycle 1 were also
analyzed in this step. As shown in Table 3, 66,67% of the students got a good category,
while the rest 33,33% got a low score category. The mean score of the class is 65.73.
Table 3
Students’ Cycle 1 Posttest Scores
Category
Frequency
Percentage
Very Good
0
0%
Good
20
66.67%
Fair
0
0%
Low
10
33.33%
Total
30
100%
Mean score: 65.73
4. Reflecting
This step was conducted to analyze the whole information and experience obtained in
Cycle 1 and reflect them to make a better plan for the next cycle. In terms of learning
media, the importance of making flashcards with big fonts and pictures was put into
priority. Two other important points were drawn from the reflection on the flashcards.
First, to make the flashcards more attractive for the students, they need to be printed in
colorful fonts and pictures. Second, the exemplary sentences printed in the flashcards
should be about events, facts, conditions or facts that are very close to the students’ daily
life. This would put the examples into contexts that are familiar to the students so that
they can be understood easily.
By comparing the results of the pretest and posttest of Cycle 1, it was found that the
learning activities in Cycle 1 managed to improve students’ achievement quite
significantly. The mean score increased from 39.6 to 65.73. However, since the mean
score in the posttest of Cycle 1 (65.73) had not reached the Standard Minimum Criteria
(75 points) the action should proceed to Cycle 2. Therefore, learning materials, activities,
and media for Cycle 2 were prepared.
Report of Cycle 2
This cycle was conducted in for sessions. It began two weeks after the end of Cycle 1, i.e.
on Monday 16 September 2019. The actions were not conducted on 9 September 2019
because the researcher needed about 10 days to prepare the action plan and flashcards to
be used in cycle 2.
46
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
1. Planning
This step was carried out to plan the topics most important to solve identified through the
analysis made on the results of the posttest of Cycle 2. In this step, I also prepared the
flashcards with readable and colorful fonts and pictures, and the sentence printed in each
flashcard was suited to the events, facts, actions, and situations that were familiar to the
students.
2. Acting
Based on the action plan, four sessions of teaching using flashcards were implemented.
The procedure employed was similar to the one used in the first cycle. The same
collaborator was asked to observe the learning process. After the four sessions were
completed, a post-test and a survey using a questionnaire which gauges the students'
perception of learning English in general and the present tense, in particular, were
administered.
3. Observing
The observation was conducted in two ways. First, the same collaborator was asked
to observe the learning process in every session. Second, data were collected through the
cycle posttest and the post-action questionnaire. The questionnaire employed was the
same as the pre-action questionnaire, but the items concerning the teacher’s lecturing
were replaced by the use of flashcards in the learning process.
As shown in Table 4, the scores obtained by the students in the posttest of Cycle 2
were much higher than the scores in the posttest of Cycle 1. Only 13.3% of the students
got the score with a very good category, one-third (66,67%) got a good category, and the
rest 20% still got low category. The mean score of the class was now 75. Since the means
score had reached the Standard Minimum Criteria (75 points), the action can be ended.
Therefore the post-action survey was administered.
Table 4
Students’ Cycle 2 Posttest Scores
Category
Frequency
Percentage
Very Good
4
13.33%
Good
20
66.67%
Fair
0
0%
Low
6
20.00%
Total
30
100%
Mean score: 75
The results of the post-action survey revealed that the two cycles implemented
changed the students' attitude to English and the simple present tense and the learning
activities. As shown in Table 5, more than 75% of the students responded positively
(selected "Yes') to every statement in the questionnaire. Before learning with flashcards,
only 33.33% of the students liked learning English (Table 2). Now 76.67% liked learning
English. Before using flashcards, only 20% viewed the simple present tense interesting,
but after learning with flashcards 83.33% viewed it interesting. Overall, the use of
flashcards to teach the simple present tense turned the students' negative attitude into a
positive attitude. The mean score of students' positive response percentage to the
statements in the pre-action survey is 20.4 (Table 2). In the post-action survey, the mean
score of the positive response percentage increased to 83.89% (Table 5).
47
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
Table 5
The Result of Post-Action Questionnaire
No
Statement
Yes
No
f
%
f
%
1
I like learning English.
23
76.67
7
23.33
2
Learning the Simple Present is interesting.
25
83.33
5
16.67
3
The Simple Present is easy to learn
22
73.33
8
26.67
4
Learning with flashcards help me understand the simple
present tense
29
96.67
1
3.33
5
The exercises on the Simple Present Tense are easy to
do
26
86.67
4
13.33
6
I like learning with flashcards
26
86.67
4
13.33
Total
151
503,54
29
96.65
Mean
25.17
83.89
4.83
16.11
4. Reflection
In this step, the whole information and experience obtained in Cycle 2 were analyzed.
The observer stated that the learning process in Cycle 2 was much more conducive than
in Cycle 1. The majority of the students were now engaged and actively participated. The
increasing mean scores of the pretest to posttest Cycle 1 and posttest Cycle 2 (Figure 1)
indicated that using flashcards is effective to improve the third graders’ mastery of the
simple resent tense.
Figure 1. Mean Scores of Pretest, Posttest 1 and Posttest 2
The findings above reveal that flashcards were effective to improve the third
graders’ mastery of the simple present tense at Permai Elementary School Jakarta. This
answers the first research question, “Does the use of the use of flashcards improve the
third graders’ mastery of the simple resent tense at Permai Elementary School, Jakarta?
Compared to their learning achievement when they were taught by listening to the
teacher’s lecture, learning the simple present tense using flashcards enabled them to
achieve higher learning results.
The answer to the second research question, “How does the use of flashcards
improve the third graders at Permai Elementary School, Jakarta?” can be related to the
effectiveness of using the flashcards to improve the students’ learning achievement. The
major contributor to the higher achievement was that flashcards are a great tool for young
36,93
65,73
75
0 20 40 60 80 100
Pretest
Posttest 1
Posttest 2
48
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
learners. The third graders involved in this study are young learners. They learn through
visual means. Since flashcards are bright, illustrative and colorful, they can have a
positive impact on the visual learning process of the students. Being young learners, they
are also imaginative and flashcards permit them to make associations. When they were
shown the sentence She wakes up at 5.00 every morning with a picture in a flashcard, the
students were facilitated to associate the sentence with the picture. They were also
allowed to relate the English sentence to their own experience. Showing the students a
flashcard with the sentence She does not wake up at 5.00 every morning and another
flashcard with the sentence Does she wake up at 5.00 every morning? The students could
compare the differences of positive, negative and interrogative sentences using the third
singular subject in the simple present tense. Accompanied by the teacher’s guidance, such
association and comparison assisted the students to grasp the abstract concept of the
simple present tense.
CONCLUSION
Based on the findings and discussion above, it can be concluded that flashcards use
managed to increase the achievement of the third graders at Permai Elementary Schoo in
learning the simple present tense. As shown by the increase of the mean score of the tests
successively administered before the action research implementation, at the end of Cycle
1 and the end of Cycle 2. The means score of these tests were 36.69, 65.73, and 75.00
respectively. Besides the increasing mastery, the use of flashcards also changed the
students’ attitudes from mainly negative to mainly positive. The mean score of the
students' positive response to the statements in the pre-action survey is 20.4% (See Table
2). In the post-action survey, the mean score of the positive response increased to 83.89%
(See Table 5).
REFERENCES
Azar, B. S. (2002). Understanding and using English grammar. New York: Longman.
Cakir, I. (2011). Problems in Teaching Tenses to Turkish Learners. Theory and Practice
in Language Studies, 1(2), 123-127, DOI: 10.4304/tpls.1.2.123-127
Cross, D. (1991). A practical handbook of language teaching. New York: Longman.
Cuban, L. (2001). Computers in the classroom. Cambridge, M.A.: Harvard University
Press.
Edwards. (2006). The use of flashcards to improve vocabulary mastery. Retrieved from:
https://www.academia.edu/23764763/THE_USE_OF_FLASHCARDS_TO_IMP
ROVE_VOCABULARY_MASTERY
Eslahcar, M. (2012). The effect of using vocabulary flash card on Iranian pre-university
students‟ vocabulary knowledge. Iran: Islamic Azad University Press
Gelfgren, V. (2012). Fun with flashcards. 150+ ideas for using flashcards in the
classroom. Learnmore Project.
Hartono (2018). The Use of Flashcard to Improve Students’ Understanding On Present
Continuous Tense For the Second Grade Students at SMA Muhammadiyah Plus
Salatiga in the Academic Year Of 2017/2018. Salatiga: State Institute for Islamic
Studies
Hill, D. A. (1990). Visual impact: Creative language learning through pictures. Essex:
Longman Group UK Limited.
49
Journal of English Teaching, Volume 6 (1), February 2020
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1061
DOI: 10.33541/jet.v6i1.1293
Sartika
Joklova, K. (2009). Using picture in teaching vocabulary. Brno: Masaryk University
Press
Kasihani, K. (2007). English for young learners. Jakarta: PT Bumi Aksara.
Male, H. (2011). Students’ View on Grammar Teaching. Journal of English Teaching,
1(1), 57-69. DOI:10.33541/jet.v1i1.52
Male, H. (2018) Playing simple grammar game as an alternative way to help primary
school students improve their grammar. Jurnal Dinamika Pendidikan. 10(3), 261-
273. DOI: https://doi.org/10.33541/jdp.v10i3.632
Muhsin, A.M. (2016). Analysing the students errors in using simple present (A case study
at junior High School in Makassar). Pacific Science Review B: Humanities and
Social Sciences, 2, 81-87
Nadziroh, A. (2010). The Use of Flashcards to Improve Vocabulary Mastery (A
Classroom Action Research for the Fourth Year Students of MI Duren Bandungan
in the Academic Year of 2009 / 2010). Salatiga: STAIN
Pardede, P. (2016). Action Research in EFL Learning and Teaching. Paper presented in
UKI’s English Education Department Collegiate Forum held on Friday, December
9, 2016
Pardede, P (2019). Seeing action research process in a practce. In Proceeding of EED
Collegiate Forum 2015-2018. EFL Theory and Practice: Voice of EED UKI,
Pardede, P. (Ed). Jakarta: UKI. pp. 282-295.
Widyarini, A. E. (2008). The Effectiveness of Using Flashcard as Teaching Media On
The Students’ Mastering of Vocabulary at Third Graders of SD (An Experimental
Study on with third graders of SD Masehi Mlaten Semarang in the academic year
of 2008/2009). Semarang: IKIP PGRI